Another Take on Lost

From Television Without Pity (its readers gave the episode an A-):

It's Role Reversal Week on Craphole Island! Once Sayid was a torturer; now he's repentant. Once Kate was useless; now she's a trained tracker. Once Locke was a crazy-eyed loon; now he's the calm voice of reason. Once Jack was the responsible, level-headed leader of the castaways; now he plunges headlong into danger, risking the lives of others. Once Walt was bad at backgammon; now he's a tournament-caliber player. Once Ethan was an anonymous Red Shirt guy; now he's evil. Once Boone was God's Friggin' Gift to Humanity; now he's God's Friggin' Gift to Wedding Planning. Once the island was made of rocks; now it's made of steel. And, finally, once, Charlie was alive; now he's dead. Oh wait, now he's alive again.