February 25, 2005 -- RYAN Seacrest's abrupt dismissal of contestants on Wednesday's live episode of "American Idol" has raised some eyebrows. Especially jolting was the way in which Melinda Lira, the first contestant booted off the show, nearly went into a state of shock when she got her abrupt marching orders from Seacrest. "Melinda, you're out," Seacrest barked at the 19-year-old from Hanford, Calif. — who covered her face as the audience sat in stunned and uncomfortable silence. Seacrest was equally abrupt with Sarah Mather, the second woman booted off the show. "Sarah, you are out," he said. Then seemed to apologize for his tone. "The journey ends for you tonight, darling. Sorry to put you through this," he said.
Passionate "Idol" fans weighed in on the show's message board yesterday — with some expressing anger over the way in which the contestants were axed. "I felt it was extremely mean, and while I'm sure they were going for the dramatic effect, these are young people with hopes and dreams," wrote one fan.
Wrote another fan of the way in which Judd Harris, the New York singer also booted off Wednesday's show, was told: " 'Judd, you're out' — you might as well hit that kid with a 2x4. It would have been less painful."
The show's producers declined to answer questions yesterday about the show's suddenly cruel turn. While "Idol" has always been known for hard knocks and bad news for losing competitors, Wednesday night's harshness seemed to stand out.
--Is this for real? Do these contestants think they'd have it any easier if they were trying to get into the music biz the traditional way? Puh-leeze!
No comments:
Post a Comment